BEST PRINTED IN "SMALLEST" SETTING ON YOUR BROWSER|
THE SECRET OF LA SALETTE
by Solange Hertz
Footnotes and Comments Added by F. John Loughnan
It is interesting to note that La Salette's Mélanie Calvat is described as "Blessed Melanie Calvat" by both
the condemned BAYSIDE visionaries and the anti-pope Gregory XVII of Canada: see
"BLESSED MELANIE CALVAT"
THE SECRET OF LA SALETTE
Little Apocalypse of Our Lady
by Solange Hertz
"Well, now, my children, you will pass this along to all my people."
With these words Mary the Mother of God concluded  the famous message she came to earth
on September 19, 1846 to deliver to two poor peasant children  employed as cowherds on the
mountain of La Salette, Famous as the message is, its full contents continue unknown to the vast
majority, not only in the world, but even in the Church. This leads one to wonder who "all Mary's
people" really are, for only these, it would seem, does it succeed in reaching, as our Lady said it
She didn't ask the children, Melanie Calvat and Maximin Giraud, to pass it along. She simply told
then they would, and that was that. And they have. Somehow, in every generation since, little
souls are found who transmit our Lady's words faithfully and quietly, although for the most part
painfully, by the most humble, nay, bumbling means, please God this may be one of them.
Outside the Gospel itself, hardly any communication from heaven has encountered such furious and
determined opposition, and that not so much outside the Church, as from within, from those members
who would be most expected to take the Secret to heart and preach it from the housetops. It has
continued unabated, despite the fact that the apparition at La Salette enjoyed almost immediately
the full approbation of the Church, with rich indulgences granted to pilgrims there, and that
canonically approved miracles have taken place on the spot. Why?
"Alas," wrote Melanie to her director Abbé Combe  in 1903, "the bishops, those who considered
themselves referred to in the Secret, are the enemies of this merciful Secret, just as the high priests
condemned the divine Savior to death! . . . And inasmuch as the Mother of God and of all Christians
by adoption at the foot of the Cross has recommended that her message in its entirety be made
known to her people, what are we waiting for to obey the Virgin Mother, seeing that every day we
behold the punishments announced by the Secret taking place? 
"What more are we waiting for, inasmuch as Holy Church has shown herself in favor insofar as She
can where revelations are concerned? Pius IX ordered  the Bishop of Grenoble to build a beautiful
Church on the mountain of La Salette. Leo XIII crowned the statue and gave the sanctuary the title
of Basilica. What more do we need to beat our breasts, to admit that all, all of us, have sinned, all
of us have provoked God's justice, all of us have set our lips to the poisoned fount of our depraved
passions, drunkenness from which plunges us into darkness? Whoever is ill-willed in regulating his
life according to the law of God, according to the maxims of the Gospel, will always find reasons for
doubting everything he wants to be in doubt about; the faith of these people is not a sanctifying
faith. . ." (Documents Pour Servir á l'Histoire Réelle de La Salette, Nouvelles Editions Latines, Paris,
In our days the Secret has been largely consigned to oblivion. In the lifetime of the visionaries some
confessors refused absolution to penitents who read it. Melanie and Maximin were subjected to
unparalleled and totally unfounded calumny and persecution. Melanie's own Bishop, along with many
other persons, made her out as insane, or at best unstable. Maximin was reputed an alcoholic. To
this day, at best, the general judgment would agree with that expressed by Fr. John Kennedy in his
Light on the Mountain: "The deficiencies and idiosyncrasies of Maximin and Melanie are but gargoyles
on the monumental, enduring fact of La Salette." La Salette, yes" Maximin, Melanie and the Secret,
After receiving the first communication from our Lady dealing with the divine displeasure at
profanations of Sunday and the Holy Name - generally propagated as the Message of La Salette 
and beyond the limits of this paper - both children were entrusted with a secret. Maximin's,
apparently never intended for the public, was carried to the grave with him. Melanie's, however,
was meant to be revealed in due time: and the moment she began doing so in obedience to
heaven, she attracted the full brunt of hell's fury.
Many good people when they heard it were convinced that Melanie had made it up, so sure were
they our Lady would never say such terrible things about the clergy. And if it's true, what good does
it do to reveal it?
To which Mélanie replied: "No, no, the Seat of Wisdom never spoke ill of the Ministers of the Altar!
Mercifully, Mary, Patroness of France. Queen of the Catholic clergy, pointed out the diseases
infecting the souls of the pastors of God's people. Those who have forgotten prayer and penance
and filled their hearts with affection for transitory things, their faith has cooled. . . Instead of
rebelling, they should have entered into themselves, revived their faith, their charity, wisely
regulating their conduct in accordance with the examples of Jesus, our divine Master and model,"
(Letter to Fr. Combe, September 1902) 
That Pius IX believed in Mélanie absolutely, indeed countering her detractors with, "Melanie is a good
girl,"  seemed to weigh little in her favor. Nor did the fact that he later relieved her of her religious
vows, which would have kept her in the cloister where the enemies of the Secret wanted her kept,
even going so far as trying to do so forcibly. She tells us, "His holiness Pius IX relieved me of such
vows as could not be kept in the world; he said that I couldn't accomplish my mission in the cloister
and he granted me privileges I would never have dared ask him." 
Badgered beyond endurance, even excommunicated by one French Bishop, Melanie eventually fled
incognito to Italy, to publish the Secret there under the protection of friendly Italian prelates. Pope
Leo XIII, who approved of Melanie as heartily as his predecessor, called her to Rome in 1879 to
confer with her not only about the Secret, but about a rule for a religious order which our Lady had
given her at the same time and wished founded immediately against the coming crisis. Specifically
the Order of the Mother of God, the "Apostles of the Latter Times" predicted by St, Louis de
Montfort, it was encouraged in every way by the Pope, who in fact kept Melanie in Rome six months
finalizing its Constitutions, but despite several abortive attempts, it always failed to materialize. (The
present religious organized under the name of La Salette do not follow this rule, nor are they in any
way connected with it.) This great work is yet to come. 
The ire of the French bishops, whom Melanie knew to be masonically controlled  pursued her
even into Italy, where she was driven from pillar to post in her attempt to remain hidden from the
world. Applying heavy pressure on Rome to have the Secret put on the Index, these high
ecclesiastics even threatened to withhold Peter's Pence from the impoverished Apostolic treasury.
This was never done, but to placate them Cardinal Caterini sent a letter from the Inquisition
forbidding Melanie in 1880 to write about or publish anything further on the Secret. 
"This unhappy letter has finished, you might say, poisoning my existence," said poor Melanie," and
has evaporated my trembling hope that by Christianity's return to its God the long and great scourges
which our prevarications deserve might be much mitigated." In great anguish she complied with the
letter. "As for me, I want to be submissive to the Holy Church of God." Nevertheless she conceded
that if she could be certain "that the Caterini letter was unknown to the Holy Father, then I would
be free to write and would write." (Letter to A. M. Schmid, of the periodical Légitimité, July 25,
Apparently never accorded this certainty, she continued obedient. Contrary to her detractors,
Melanie's life was one of high virtue, austerity and prayer, her apparent eccentricities and "instability"
due almost entirely to her fidelity to her mission and her determination to keep herself and her many
extraordinary gifts (among them the stigmata)  hidden from public view. On reading an account
of her life in 1910, Pope St. Pius X exclaimed to the Bishop of Altamura, in whose diocese she had
died and was buried, "La nostra Santa!" He suggested to the Bishop that her cause for beatification
be introduced immediately. 
Testimony to her holiness is plentiful if one knows where to look, but that of the Fr. Rigaux, her last
director,  should suffice: "In the 48 years that I've been a priest, I've known and directed some
very beautiful souls. I dare state before God, who will soon judge me, that never have I encountered
a soul so humble, gentle, pure, obedient a virgin so pure, a character so strong, a victim so resigned
in frightful trials, a martyr in body, bearing the stigmata from her tenderest years."
Melanie died at the age of 72, alone and unattended, on December 14, 1904, but she left us the
Secret. It's extraordinary how many people today are still hesitant about reading it, let alone
believing it, because they think it was on the Index. Nothing could be further from the truth. 
Although it's true that several publications dealing with it were condemned - some of them with very
good reason - the Secret itself has never suffered any official condemnation.  As a matter of
fact there is extant a letter from Fr. Lepidi, Master of the Sacred Palace, dated December 16, 1912
to Cardinal Luçon, stating officially, that the Secret of La Salette has never been condemned by the
Index nor by the Holy Office. 
Delivered orally hundreds of times by Melanie herself. It was first published under the Imprimatur of
the Bishop of Naples. It appeared a second time under the Imprimatur of Salvatore Zola, Bishop of
Lecce, Italy, who gave his permission after consulting with Leo XIII on the matter.  This edition
was reprinted ne varietur in France in 1904, a few months before Melanie died. 
In the meantime the full text had been examined by the congregation of the Index, which found no
change necessary.  When Leo XIII read it initially, not only did he voice no objection, but he
ordered a version with fuller explanations to be undertaken!  The Bishops of Arras and bayonne
granted further Imprimaturs in 1893, followed by many others throughout Christendom. Fr. Rigaux,
writing around the turn of the century, stated that he had in his possession "28 editions of the
Secret, with Imprimatur from Cardinals and Bishops."
Nevertheless, as Mélanie wrote then, "With Imprimatur and all the Imprimaturs, I wonder who will
believe the teachings of an apparition, when almost the whole Church of God no longer believes in
the Gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ. Or if she does believe, it's only with the faith of the intellect
and not with the faith of the will." (May 19, 1904) Although never placed on the Index, the Secret
suffered grievous impediments due to the cause Melanie saw so well. It must be forcibly noted here
that by a decree of the Holy Office dated December 21, 1915, all the faithful are forbidden to write
commentaries or interpretations of the Secret. As far as can be ascertained, this decree is still in
effect and must be obeyed. 
But are commentaries really necessary? As Mélanie told her director in 1903, "souls who are God's
friends can guess the Secret's meaning without help, and the others won't want to because it applies
to them too closely." When all is said and done, "The Secret only proposes observance of God's law,
and complains of the lack of observance of this same law, and it threatens the transgressors of this
holy law with chastisements and scourges." Pope Plus IX summed it up even more briefly: "If you
don't do penance you will perish!" 
If this was clear at the turn of the century. It's even clearer now for those with eyes to see. Hardly
any soul of good will needs help interpreting the Secret of La Salette today. It has become an open
secret if ever there was one. In the same letter to her director  just quoted Melanie explained
to him exactly the sort of thing our Lady was referring to when she said,
"There are two holy places: the Church and the spouse, or if you prefer, the soul which no longer
belongs to herself. In 1865 there passed like a gust of rebellion: an archbishop who poisoned a king;
cardinals and others sold the great See of Catholicism, after having become fathers several times,
and events of like nature, it's a long story. But nobody knows about it you say? Haven't we heard
tell that Napoleon, Garibaldi, Gambetta and certain priests were in the habit of visiting convents from
time to tine, that they were very charitable towards these nuns? and that in other countries or
kingdoms the rendezvous took place in churches? And hasn't Freemasonry been solemnly
established, that is to say, recognized? But it's useless. I'm not capable of uncovering the
stratagems, the brood of crimes which only apathy and frenzy for pleasure have hidden from the
eyes of those who already no longer see. We shall see: it's not everyone who will see, but those
souls nearest to the spotless light!" She concludes, "At most we can say that God is reproaching
us with the same crimes which caused the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah to perish by fire from
The prohibition against her publishing anything about the Secret must have weighed on her ever
more heavily as she saw public morality sink lower and lower, for apparently she had been given to
understand very much more than our Lady's words conveyed on the surface. Speaking of the
apparition she says, "Each word develops and the future action takes place within the moment, and
thousands and thousands more things are seen than the ears hear...One sees plots hatching, one
sees the kings of the earth, each of whom has several guardian angels;  one sees them moving
about, doing, undoing; one sees the jealousy of some, the ambition of others, etc., and all that in
one word escaping from the lips of her who makes hell tremble." (Letter to Fr. Bliard)
In 1897 she mourned to Fr. Combe, "God used to speak continually to His prophets and they weren't
held to obedience to...when this was contrary to God's will. Today one must obey or be struck with
excommunication.  I can only groan at the lamentable state of our loving Jesus'
Yet, even given permission, Mélanie would have been powerless to transmit it all. To the pious and
zealous Fr. Roubaud - who had hoped in the beginning  to publish a volume on the subject from
her pen - she said, "I don't feel I have the grace to explain. The world isn't disposed to hear it.
What's more, the little people of God don't need to touch with the finger. Our sweet Mother Mary
didn't come for believers, but for those who don't practice the promises made at their baptism." She
had prefaced this with the rueful comment, "It's possible, and it's even certain, that the Jews will
re-assume their title of people of God and perhaps we shall be rejected."
Melanie was not acquainted with the famous prophecy of St. Malachy, but in 1894 she told this
good priest that among the future events she saw unrolling in the course of the apparition, "I didn't
see, I don't see, any Great Pope  or Great Monarch before an extremely great tribulation,
horrifying, terrible and general for all Christendom. But before that time, twice there will be a
short-lived peace two shaky, servile, doubtful popes." [33}
Anyone who thinks the crisis In the Church we suffer today began with the Second Vatican Council
need only read Melanie's correspondence. The following extracts from her letters to Fr. Roubaud
are a fair sample:
"When the Secret has been scorned, misunderstood ... held back for money,  one must be
surprised at nothing. The Church will endure forever, our Lord said so; but among the teaching
members of the Church, what traitors, what apostates, what mercenaries, what sectarians, who
bear the imprint or the sign of the beast with ten horns St. John speaks of in his vision on Patmos!
But this beast similar to the Lamb, who rises out of the earth, isn't it the figure of faithless
ecclesiastics? I firmly believe so. Happy those who die in God's grace, for those who live will see
sad and terrifying things. We still haven't reached the beginning of the end." (January 2, 1892)
Later the same year, her words apropos  of a good priest who was losing his eyesight have sadly
increased in relevance today: "Oh, how God afflicts His true servants in these times! But this
affliction is a punishment for the half-Christians who have rendered themselves unworthy of hearing
the word of truth, which they obstinately refuse to put into practice. When God favored us, when
He was giving us all we needed, we abandoned Him; now we blaspheme Him like the damned. God
was giving us His graces in manifold ways, now He deprives us of everything.  He plays deaf,
indifferent, as we did towards Him. We have nothing to say. And now He is taking from us the few
good priests who, despite all the thunderbolts of those sold for gold, never ceased teaching us the
practice of the Christi virtues and flight from sin... 
"... You'd think the devil would keep quiet inasmuch as men are almost all working for him, for his
triumph. Well, no, he turns himself into an angel of light, aping true apparitions, truly divine. Later
he'll show his horns, in order to destroy the true divine apparitions by his impostures. It's noteworthy
that in all these false apparition there are always many flattering words directed to certain persons,
which these seers, seeing only the devil, apply to some gullible person wrapt in refined self-love. It's
also true there are visionaries without visions, who don't even need the devil's help, being themselves
The rash of false signs and wonders, tongues and prophecies soliciting our attention so generally now
was evidently well under way in the last century. On September 9, 1894, she writes, "The devil is a
liar, what he says mustn't be believed because if he says something true, it's preceded and followed
by lies and wrapped In obscurity. The good Lord doesn't permit His true worshippers to be playthings
of evil spirits at their expense. Today already in the world, in families (Christian in appearance) there
are supernatural-diabolic things; these are treated as illness, and bit by bit the serpent's wonders
insinuate themselves noiselessly into society - Mistrust of self, deep and true humility, supreme love
of God alone can deliver these souls from the eternal abysses. It seems to me, if I'm not mistaken,
that we don't have to wait for the reign of the Antichrist to see apostates behind masks; today we
have a great number, whom Satan recognizes as his own. The sentinels of the sanctuary have
passed into the enemy camp!!! The divine supernatural has been scorned! We'll be taken in the nets
of the diabolic supernatural." 
Sad to say, that Melanie prophesied truly here can now be demonstrated. All the more reason,
therefore, to heed the Secret. Why risk setting our sights to doubtful prophecies from lesser
sources? The words of the greatest saints can never measure up to those of the Mother of God,
whose motherly apocalypse could rank second only to that of our Lord himself spoken in the Gospels
and through St. John on Patmos. 
With this thought in mind we can proceed to a first hand reading of the authentic Secret. The
accompanying part is that of the definitive 1904 edition, of which Melanie said in April of that year
to Fr. Rigaux: "The Secret is word for word that of our gentle Mother, just as I gave it to His Holiness
Leo XIII in 1879." The following October she wrote, "I protest highly against a differing text, which
people may dare publish after my death, I protest once more against the very false statements of
all those who dare say and write: First, that I embroidered the Secret; second, against those who
state that the Queen of Wisdom did not say to transmit the Secret to all her people."
We might note here that the Secret was given to Mélanie in French. Although she spoke only patois
at the tine and learned French later, she was able to understand the message, and retained it
perfectly word for word. When a gentleman asked her as a child how such a thing was possible,
she answered, simply, "I don't know. If the holy Virgin so willed it, sir, I understood." Our translation
may be rather stiff in spots, but every effort was made to hew as closely as possible to the original,
inasmuch as in a communication of this kind a change in the nuance of one word can shift the
The Secret must be allowed to speak for itself, coming to us as it does from our Lady herself. A true
apocalypse, it must be read like all apocalyptic literature, which uses enigma and metaphor precisely
so that only those for whom it is intended may grasp its true meaning. Let him who reads
understand. Our Lady's own people, by supernatural instinct, will know not to take its terms in their
purely literal sense, any more than they would in reading the Apocalypse of St. John. For instance,
they would know better than to take in a carnal sense the "Hebrew nun," the "false virgin" who is to
bear the Antichrist as a result of relations with a Bishop. Genuine apocalyptic messages deal
primarily in spiritual matters. These are clothed in material imagery designed to give the clue to the
meaning, but which remains secondary. Nor is there any strict chronology sometimes the same
event is described in different ways.
Even so, only the light of the Holy Ghost, supported by prayer, penance and innocence of life can
unlock divine mysteries for the human intellect, which no amount of purely human explanation can
enlighten in such matters. This makes obeying the Decree of 1915 rather easy, for as Melanie said,
commentaries are largely useless anyway. 
Who will not heed Mélanie may heed St. Gregory the Great: "... Unless the same Spirit is in the
heart of the one who learns, unprofitable is the word of the teacher ... Unless He is within who will
teach us, the tongue of the teacher labors in vain. All alike hear the voice of the speaker, yet all do
not understand alike the meaning of the words they hear. Since the word is the same, why do your
hearts not understand alike, if not for the reason that, although the voice of the speaker is directed
towards all, it is the Master within us who teaches us what is said, and some more than others?"
(Serno 30 In Evangelia)
We can do no better than to introduce the Secret with the same words Melanie used before setting
down her recital of the marvelous happening at La Salette:
"I obey the most holy Virgin Mother of God and Mother of all believers. I submit this publication to
the judgment of the Holy Apostolic See, and I declare condemned in advance all found therein
contrary to Catholic doctrine:"
Copyright Solange Hertz 1974
Minus, of course, the footnotes!
- The Blessed Virgin's opening words were: "Come, My children, do not be afraid: I am here to
proclaim great news to you." The claim that Our Lady would subsequently state that "Rome will lose
the Faith and become the seat of antichrist," is "great news"???
- The Catholic Encyclopedia, (c) 1910 describes "both of them very ignorant."
- Her spiritual director is the same Abbé Gilbert-Joseph-Emile Combe whose writings on the Secret
of La Salette were placed on the Index of Prohibited Books in 1901 and again in 1907.
The Diocese of San Bernardino, California,
among others, carries an article on Mélania Calvat from including a passage on Abbé Combe:
"...she was invited by the Abbé Combe, pastor of Dion, a priest much taken up with politico-religious
prophecies, to settle in the Allier region. She finished a contrived autobiography, etc."
- "In fact, Milanie yields to prophetic delirium, taken from the Old Testament then from Saint
Louis-Marie Grignion de Montfort. She furiously spits out her personal hatreds, which she nurtures;
she is fierce against those many priests and bishops who rebuffed her - the bad priests because
they were bad, the good ones because they found the Secret revolting! Whence 'the priests are
a cesspool of iniquity'.
"Likewise, her political ideas are dictated by her passions: Mgr Ginoulhiac was favourable to Napoleon
III, he chased her out of Corenc, therefore she is opposed to Napoleon III! who was 'a two-faced
being!' But she did not reveal that before Napoleon III was known! Had she been very intelligent, or
very inspired, she could have said that from 2 December 1851!"
The Truth About the Secret of La Salette
- No evidence is offered (apart from the alleged quote from Mélanie Calvat, taken from a
publication of 1963-66) for the statement that "Pius IX ordered the Bishop of Grenoble to build . . ."
The Catholic Encyclopedia simply states"
"Despite these hostile acts, the first stone of a great church was solemnly laid on the mount of La
Salette, 25 May, 1852. . . This Church, later elevated to the rank of a basilica . . ." The hostile acts,
it states, came from "a violent opposition aggravated by what is known as the incident of Ars. As a
result of this hostility and the consequent agitation, Mgr. De Bruillard (16 November 1851) declared
the apparition of the Blessed Virgin as certain, and authorized the cult of Our Lady of La Salette."
- For the "Secret of La Salette" formed no part whatsoever in the approval of the apparition and
cult of La Salette:
"With this in mind, Bishop Ginouliac, on September 19, 1855, proclaimed the following from the holy
mountain itself: 'The mission of the shepherds is herewith ended, that of the Church begins."
Unfortunately, Mélanie pursued her prophetic meandering. Later, these were orchestrated by the
blazing talent of a Leon Bloy and would become a 'Melanist' movement allegedly stemming from La
Salette, but lacking any foundation except the unverifiable pronouncements of Mélanie."
Diocese of San Bernardino, California,
- The Message of La Salette is provided by irreproachable sources such as
and the Missionaries of La Salette at
- This is simply a gratuitous allegation, which is not in accordance with the September 19, 1855
proclamation of Bishop Ginouliac (the local Apostle placed in La Salette for THAT time) -see above
- Solange Hertz presents an "opposition" who (in bad faith?) disbelieve that the Blessed Virgin
would speak ill of the clergy - perhaps they were right; it is Mélanie herself who speaks of "the
bishops, those who considered themselves referred to in the Secret, are the enemies of this merciful
Secret . . . whom Mélanie knew to be masonically controlled . . ."!
- That Pius IX believed in Mélanie absolutely, indeed countering her detractors with, "Melanie is a
good girl," is simple unstubstantiatable rhetoric. It is a bit like saying (and requiring everyone to
believe): Count Von Trappe believed absolutely that Mary Poppins liked strawberry jam on her
crousants." How on earth can one probe the mind of a now long dead pope? What did Pope Pius IX
DO to demonstrate the contention? And, in any event, was it authorative?
- I cannot but help wonder if the alleged words of Pope Pius IX are recorded anywhere but in the
writings of Mélanie? Mrs Hertz does not provide a supporting reference.
- As a matter of fact, it has materialized - well, sort of: Gaston Tremblay, a.k.a. "Pope" Gregory
XVII (1968) operates (I am not sure if he is still living.)
"The Order of the Magnificat of the Mother of God" as "requested by the Blessed Virgin at La Salette
(France) in 1846, and was founded in Canada in 1962. This religious Order, destined to form the
Apostles of the Latter Times, received a mission for the preservation of the Deposit of the Catholic
Christian Faith and the safeguard of the Universal Church. Today it is established in several
- according to the website The Order of the
Magnificat of the Mother of God They operate out of St Jovite, Quebec, Canada.
This group has also beatified "Blessed Mélanie
Another condemned apparitionist group which calls Mélanie "Blessed" are the Bayside group which
originated with Veronica Lueken.
So, Solange! It's happened! Trouble is that they are schismatics and excommunicants from the
Catholic Church. Still, that should not worry Solange; she could probably be aptly described as
the "mother of all traditionalists"!
- So, Mélanie, who the Catholic Encyclopedia described as being "very ignorant", just "knew"
that the Bishops were "masonically controlled" - whatever that means. I guess it might mean that,
just as perhaps a majority of U.S.A., or English, or Australian members of government might be
members of the Masonic Lodge, then it could be said that the U.S.A. and English and Australian
bishops are "masonically controlled."? But, Mélanie and/or Solange appear to put a more sinister
meaning to the expression.
- See chronology below.
- Her autobiography would be published in 1900.
- Stigmata? While I do not mean to equate Mélamie with her - Magdalena de la Cruz also had a
stigmata! - but was possessed by the devil for about 30 years.
- Whose account is not revealed; was it Mélanie's autobiography? In the event, Pope St. Pius X's
alleged remark progressed no-where.
- The CRC reports the following about the fall-out between Mélanie Calvat and Abbé Combe:
"Back in Italy, at Messina and then at Moncalien, in 1899, Mélanie, on the insistence of Abbé Combe, who was infatuated with her, returned to France, changing her address three times. Stormy relations with this priest made her flee to Italy again, in 1904. On leaving, they told each other a piece of their mind. He, that he is now persuaded that she is subject to illusion and that she does not see 'everything in God'. She, that her former confessor and protector wanted to wrench all her secrets from her, and that he lacked intelligence and humility in wanting to interrupt God's will for her, in his way (cf. Guilhot, p.481). On the 15th December 1904, she was found dead in her house at Altanura. What a life! And what an end!"
- The last published INDEX LIBRORVM PROHIBITORVM was in 1948. It has five entries on La
Salette - as follows:
Now, let us return to one of the entries in the ACTS OF THE APOSTOLIC SEE, - the last one Dated
at Rome, May, 10, 1923. Here is the actual condemnation as published in the Acts of the Apostolic
- Apparition (L') de la Très Sainte Vierge de la Salette. 1923
- Combe, Gilbert-Joseph-Emile
Le grand coup avec sa date probable, c'est-à-dire le grand châtiment du monde et le triomphe
universel de l'Eglise; étude sur le secret de la Salette, augmentée de la brochure de Mélanie et
autres pièces justificatives.
- Combe, Gilbert-Joseph-Emile
Le secret de Mélanie, bergère de la Salette, et la crise actuelle.
- Mariavé, Henri
La leçon de l'hôpital Notre-Dame, d'Ypres; exégèse du secret de la Salette.
- Salette (La)
L'apparition de la Très Sainte Vierge.
DAMNATUR OPUSCULUM: "L'APPARITION DE LA TRÉS SAINTE VIERGE DE LA SALETTE"
"L'apparition de la trés Sainte Vierge sur la montague de la Salette le samedi septembre 1846. -
Simple réimpression du texte intégral publié par Mélanie, etc. Societé Saint - Augustin,
10 May 1923
- For the very good reason that the alleged "secret/message" of 1879 and 1904 is not that which
was delivered to the Holy See in 1851.
- The very same 40-page brochure was the subject of the May 1923 PROHIBITION in the Index
of Forbidden Books. The June 1922 Imprimatur of Fr. or Bishop Lepidi was trumped by the Holy Office
May 1923 OFFICIAL prohibition. Mrs Hertz, of course, tries to denigrate the efficacy of that
- The alleged threat from "high ecclesiastics. . .to withhold Peter's Pence from the impoverished
Apostolic treasury," and the alleged "consultation" with Leo XIII notwithstanding, "Cardinal Caterini
sent a letter from the Inquisition forbidding Melanie in 1880 to write about or publish anything further
on the Secret." - according to Mrs Hertz!
- Re-printed despite the 1880: letter from Cardinal Caterini from the Inquisition forbidding Melanie
"to write about or publish anything further on the Secret." And, despite the fact that Mélanie was
"apparently never accorded this certainty . . . ", writing: 'that [if] the Caterini letter was unknown
to the Holy Father, then I would be free to write and would write.'
- What change was possible? Had Cardinal Caterini's order been revoked?
- And during his reign, the following acts had been actualized:
Where is there any record of Pope Leo XIII actually promoting the "Secret/message" apart from the
say-so of Solange Hertz? This statement only demonstrates that, if true, Pope Leo XIII thought that
the "secret/message" was deficient.
- "Cardinal Caterini sent a letter from the Inquisition forbidding Melanie in 1880 to write about or
publish anything further on the Secret."
- The writings of Abbé Combe on the Secret of La Salette were placed on the Index of Prohibited
Books for the first time in 1901.
- "Decree of the Holy Office dated December 21, 1915, all the faithful are forbidden to write
commentaries or interpretations of the Secret. As far as can be ascertained, this decree is still in
effect and must be obeyed."
In fact, the Decree does much more than Solange Hertz claims. Ii includes:
"So that these abuses which oppose true piety and greatly wound ecclesiastical authority might be
curbed, the same Sacred Congregation orders all the faithful of any region not to discuss or
investigate under any pretext, neither through books, or little works or articles, whether signed or
unsigned, or in any other way of any kind, about the mentioned subject. Whoever, indeed, violates
this precept of the Holy Office, if they are priests, are deprived of all dignity and suspended by the
local ordinary from hearing sacramental confessions and from offering Mass: and, if they are lay
people, they are not permitted to the sacraments until they repent.
And, yes, it's moral force IS still in effect!
"Moreover, let people be subject to the sanctions given both by Pope Leo XIII through the
Constitution of the offices and responsibilities against those who publish books dealing with religious
things without legitimate permission of superiors and by Urban VIII through the decree "Sanctissimus
Dominus Noster" given on 13th March 1625 against those who publish asserted revelations without
the permission of ordinaries."
- And, that actually sums it up!
- Although Mrs Hertz does not say so, presumably the director at this time was still the Abbé
Combe, for it is not until the next year, 1904, that Mélanie and Abbé Combe split-up. We are told
that "Fr. Rigaux, [was] her last director."
- That kings have several guardian angels is an interesting speculation. The Church teaches that
every person has a Guardian Angel. At what stage might a person (who is not yet a king) with a
Guardian Angel attain more Guardian Angels? Would it only be subsequent to his coronation? And,
what if this new king had become king due to his murdering his predecessor? Doesn't the mind
boggle? What if the king went mad - for example like King George III of England? Would there still be
the need for several guardian angels? One thing is certain: the proposition is not required to be
believed by Catholics or anyone else!
- Was she, indeed, "threatened with excommunication"? This would be interesting to follow-up.
- Presumably, Mrs Hertz's "from the beginning" means from the time, in 1904, that he became
Mélanie's "last director"? But, later Mrs Hertz indicates that Melanie knew this "last director" in 1894.
- Not even Pope St. Pius X - was he not a great pope?
- "...two shaky, servile, doubtful popes..." Of Course, Solange Hertz would equate this passage
to the post Vatican II popes. Now! Which two were the shaky, servile, doubtful popes among Popes
John XXIII, Paul VI, John I and John-Paul II? Hmmmmmmmmmm!
- "Held back for money" - what is meant here? Who was "holding back", and who was "holding
- On the contrary, Mélanie speaks heresy here. It is Catholic Dogma that
- Despite men's sins God truly and earnestly desires the salvation of all men. (Sent. fidei
- God gives all the just sufficent grace (gratia proxime vel remote sufficiens) for the observation
of the Divine Commandments. (De fide.)
- Here she describes a capricious God; one who plays with humanity!
- What false apparitions is Mélanie talking about here? Obviously, some that occurred between
1846 and 1904! Certainly the devil attempts to derogate in order to minimize or discredit authentic
But what were some of the alleged apparitions in this time frame which were diabolic?
- But there is nothing new here that cannot have been previously said - and said better!
- And, yet it is so starkly in contrast to the message of Lourdes. And Lourdes, like so many others
were so less verbose. At Knock, Our Lady said - nothing!
- Here we have the apparitionists and integrists charter for disobedience! If you do not "like" a
Decree from Rome - disobey it!
- 1851, Nov. 16: Mgr. De Bruillard declared the apparition of the Blessed Virgin as certain, and
authorized the cult of Our Lady of La Salette.
- 1851, July 3: Short version of the "Secret" written down and delivered to the Pope on July 18.
- 1852, May 25: The first stone of a great church was solemnly laid on the mount of La Salette. T
his Church, later elevated to the rank of a basilica."
- 1855, Sep. 19: Proclaimed the following from the holy mountain itself: "The mission of the
shepherds is herewith ended, that of the Church begins."
- 1872, April 9: Pius IX in an Allocution on this day said: "I do not give much belief to prophecies, because those
especially that have come recently do not deserve to be read." (cf. Discernment of Spirits)
- 1873: As we will see in a passage below, the claim is made that The Secret of La Salette "was first published in 1873
under the Imprimatur of the Bishop of Naples."
Yet elsewhere, the
same Solamge Hertz writes:
"Her critics maintain that the text of the Secret with which we are familiar and which Mélanie FIRST
published in its entirety in 1879 under the imprimatur of Bishop Salvatore-Luigi Zola of Lecce,
Italy was her own expanded and embroidered version of our Lady's real message, which Piux IX had
requested her to submit to him in 1851. Emphasizing the difference in length between the the two
versions of the Secret, the short one set down in 1851 for the Pope and the longer one delivered
to the public in 1879, some hold that Mélanie added to the original text information culled from
contemporary apocalyptic literature then in circulation. Mélanie's autobiographical writings, particularly
those dealing with her abused childhood and her miraculous companionship with the child Jesus, are
rejected as spurious by many."
- 1878, November 21: Mélanie completed her "own account of the apparition, together with the
full text of the Secret, which she had set in writing in Castellamare, Italy on the feast of our Lady's
Presentation, November 21, 1878 and which received an Imprimatur the following year from the local
Ordinary, Bishop Zola." Solange Hertz on The Secret of La Salette
- 1879: "It appeared a second time [or, was it the FIRST time??? as Solange Hertz writes elsewhere!!!]
under the Imprimatur of Salvador Zola, Bishop of Lecce, Italy."
Again, from Solange Hertz: "But the secret in its entirety was made public ONLY in the little
work written by Mélanie herself and printed in Lecce in 1879 at the request of a pious person."
- 1880: ". . . high ecclesiastics [threatened] to withhold Peter's Pence from the impoverished
Apostolic treasury," and "Cardinal Caterini sent a letter from the Inquisition forbidding Melanie in
1880 to write about or publish anything further on the Secret."
"Nevertheless she conceded that if she could be certain 'that the Caterini letter was unknown to the
Holy Father, then I would be free to write and would write.'. . . [But, she was ] Apparently never
accorded this certainty . . . "
- 1893: "The Bishops of Arras and Bayonne granted further Imprimaturs. . ."
- 1899, Mélanie, on the insistence of Abbé Gilbert-Joseph-Emile Combe, who was infatuated with
her, returned to France, changing her address three times.
- 1889c: Fr Rigaux records: "28 editions of the Secret, with Imprimatur from Cardinals and
- 1900: Mélanie's autobiography would be published.
- 1901: The writings of Abbé Combe on the Secret of La Salette were placed on the Index of
Prohibited Books in 1901 and again in 1907.
- 1904: The Zola Imprimatured "edition was reprinted ne varietur in France. . ."
- 1904: Stormy relations with Abbé Combe made Mélanie flee to Italy again. They "told each other
a piece of their mind."
- 1904, Dec. 15: Mélanie was found dead in her house at Altanura.
- 1907: The writings of Abbé Combe on the Secret of La Salette were again placed on the Index
of Prohibited Books in 1907 (as in 1901).
- 1910: The Catholic Encyclopedia, (c) 1910 describes Mélanie and Maximin "both of them very
- 1912, Dec. 16: Mrs Hertz states that "Fr. Lepidi, Master of the Sacred Palace, dated December
16, 1912 to Cardinal Luçon, stating officially, that the Secret of La Salette has never been
condemned by the Index nor by the Holy Office."
- First of all, since when does a "Father" have the authority to state "officially" anything on
behalf of the Holy Office?
- Secondly, the La Salette website at http://www.nsrasalette.org.br/ingles.htm states: that
Mélanie resided "at Castellamare di Stabia, near Naples, Italy. She resided there seventeen years,
writing her 'secrets' as well as a rule for a future foundation. The Vatican urged the local bishop to
forbid her this type of publication, but she persisted in her search for approbation and an imprimatur,
even extracting a hearing from a papal official, Bishop Lepidi. This, however, never constituted
even a veiled approval. The authority invoked by Mélanie is incompetent in the matter." Well, it
appears that Mrs Hertz may have been wrong on the status of "Father" Lepidi. What else? But she
invokes Fr. Lepidi again in 1922. See 1922.
- 1915, Dec. 21: "Decree of the Holy Office dated December 21, 1915, all the faithful are forbidden
to write commentaries or interpretations of the Secret. As far as can be ascertained, this decree is
still in effect and must be obeyed."
- 1922: Mrs Hertz writes: "Most of them [the hard facts] can be found in a 40-page brochure in
defense of the Secret which was published in French in 1922, bearing the Imprimatur, dated June 6
of that year, of no less an authority than the Dominican Fr. Albert Lepidi, then Master of the Sacred
Palace and Permanent Consultor to the Congregation of the Index.
Desseminated by the St Augustine Society under the title "The Apparition of the Most Blessed Virgin
on the Mountain of La Salette,"...the first half of the brochure contains Mélanie's own account of the
apparition, together with the full text of the Secret, which she had set in writing in Castellamare, Italy
on the feast of our Lady's Presentation, November 21, 1878 and which received the Imprimatur the
following year from the local Ordinary, Bishop Zola.
I think that Mrs Hertz has shot herself in the foot, so to say. Not only does she contradict the 1873
claim, but she quotes the precise desseminator and brochure which was the subject of the May 10,
1923 placement on the Index of Forbidden books
It should go without saying that the placing of the brochure on the INDEX by the Holy Office trumped
the June 1922 Imprimatur of Fr. or Bishop Lepidi. Mrs Hertz, of course, tries to downgrade the
duty of obedience required in respect of that Decree.
- 1923, May 10: Prohibited: - "L'apparition de la trés Sainte Vierge sur la montague de la Salette
le samedi septembre 1846. - Simple réimpression du texte intégral publié par Mélanie, etc. Societé
Saint - Augustin, Paris-Rome-Bruges, 1922"